BestsellerShop at Manta Sleep ↗Versus
Manta vs Therabody SleepMask: the $39 Manta is the better buy for most sleepers
For most people, the Manta Sleep Mask at $39 is the better buy. Its adjustable, contoured eye cups sit around your eyes instead of pressing on them, so it blocks light and you can still blink. The Therabody SleepMask at $109.99 is worth the extra only if you want its three built-in vibration patterns as part of winding down, and you do not mind charging a sleep mask. Want to check out on Glow instead? The Loftie Sleep Mask at $25.99 is the easy, washable pick, and the KAILU Original Oversized Silk Eye Mask at $68 is the silk one. Skip all of them if light is not what wakes you up.
Links marked ↗ go to other shops. We may earn a commission. It never changes our take.
The short answer: For most people, the Manta Sleep Mask at $39 is the better buy. Its adjustable, contoured eye cups sit around your eyes instead of pressing on them, so it blocks light and you can still blink. The Therabody SleepMask at $109.99 is worth the extra only if you want its three built-in vibration patterns as part of winding down, and you do not mind charging a sleep mask. Want to check out on Glow instead? The Loftie Sleep Mask at $25.99 is the easy, washable pick, and the KAILU Original Oversized Silk Eye Mask at $68 is the silk one. Skip all of them if light is not what wakes you up.
Updated November 17, 2026.
Sleep your main thing? Take the 60-Second Quiz, or browse Sleep picks that check out on Glow.
Disclosure: Manta and Therabody are Shop at picks: the link opens the brand's site, and we may earn a commission. Loftie and KAILU masks are Ships from: the partner brand ships it, and you check out with us. Neither changes the verdict, and we label both every time. No brand paid for placement. Read our affiliate disclosure and how we pick. This is an editorial comparison built from each brand's own product details, not a lab test or a wear trial.
The verdict, in one table
| Manta Sleep Mask | Therabody SleepMask | Loftie Sleep Mask | KAILU Oversized Silk | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price on our page, Nov 17, 2026 | $39 | $109.99 | $25.99 | $68 |
| Checks out on Glow | No, Shop at Manta Sleep | No, Shop at Therabody | Yes, Ships from | Yes, Ships from |
| How it blocks light | Adjustable contoured eye cups | 100% blackout fit, per the brand | Hidden eye cups, triangle band | Nearly 5 inches wide |
| Extras | None, and that is the point | 3 quiet vibration patterns, rechargeable | Synthetic silk that the brand says won't pill in the wash | OEKO-TEX certified mulberry silk |
| Pressure on the eyes | Cups sit around the eyes | Not detailed beyond the blackout fit | Less pressure on the face, per the brand | Strap sits off the lashes |
| Our pick if | You want the best mask for the money | You want a wind-down gadget | You want Glow checkout under $30 | You want silk on your face |
What you are actually buying
Manta is a mask built around one idea: block light without pressing on your eyes. The eye cups move, so you can position them for your face. That is why it shows up on side sleepers' nightstands and in carry-ons.
Therabody SleepMask is a blackout mask with a small extra: three quiet vibration patterns meant for winding down. It is rechargeable. You are paying about $70 more than Manta for that vibration, so the real question is whether you want it.
That makes this an easy call for most people. If you only want darkness, buy the Manta. If the vibration is the gift, buy the Therabody.
Manta Sleep Mask, $39
The practical upgrade. Adjustable, contoured eye cups block light while leaving room to blink, and it comes in Classic, Sunrise Pink and Carbon Black.
Skip it if: you want the softest thing on your face. A silk mask feels nicer, it just does not block light the same way.
The catch: eye cups take a minute to adjust the first night. Do it before you are tired.
Therabody SleepMask, $109.99
A blackout fit plus three quiet vibration patterns, in a rechargeable mask. This is the one for someone who already likes a little sensory cue at bedtime, and the one that feels like a real present.
Skip it if: you just want it dark. Manta does that for $39.
The catch: it is one more thing to charge, and it costs nearly three Manta masks.
If you want to check out on Glow
Loftie Sleep Mask, $25.99, Ships from
Synthetic silk that the brand says doesn't pill or fall apart in the wash, with hidden eye cups and a triangle band so it sits with less pressure on the face. Black, orange or bordeaux. Loftie ships it, and you check out on Glow.
Skip it if: you want real mulberry silk. That is KAILU, below.
The catch: it is synthetic silk, and the brand does not claim full blackout.
KAILU Original Oversized Silk Eye Mask, $68, Ships from
OEKO-TEX certified mulberry silk, cut nearly five inches wide so it covers more of the eye area and blocks light at the edges. A gentle elastic strap sits off your lashes. Black or emerald. KAILU ships it, and you check out on Glow.
Skip it if: you need blackout for a sunrise bedroom. A flat silk mask is about comfort first.
The catch: $68 is a lot for a flat mask. You are paying for the silk.
The best sleep mask by sleeper
- Side sleepers who want full blackout: Manta PRO Sleep Mask, $85. C-shaped eye cups designed for side sleeping, zero pressure on lids or lashes, and 100% blackout, per the brand.
- Silk plus eye cups: Manta SILK Sleep Mask, $75. 30 momme mulberry silk with adjustable deep eye cups.
- Lash extensions: Kitsch Blush Contour Pillow Eye Mask, $35, contoured memory foam that keeps pressure off lashes. The splurge version is the Slip Black Contour Sleep Mask, $79, which Slip says may not suit every lash length.
- Weighted feel: Blissy Weighted Sleep Mask, $65.95, mulberry silk with gentle pressure, and you can use it warm or cool.
- Under $25: Hostage Blindfold Sleep Mask, $24.95, memory foam with 3D eye cups.
Skip a sleep mask if
- Noise wakes you, not light. Look at earplugs or a sound machine. Our Hatch Restore 3 vs Loftie Clock piece covers the bedside side.
- You hate anything on your face. Blackout curtains are the no-strap answer.
- You can't sleep for reasons a mask won't touch. If poor sleep is ongoing, talk to a doctor.
The ritual: one minute
- Put the mask on the nightstand, not in a drawer. Easy to reach is easy to keep.
- Adjust the strap and cups while you are still awake.
- Mask on as the last thing, after your phone goes on the charger across the room.
- Wash it on the brand's schedule. A mask sits on your skin all night.
FAQ
Is the Therabody SleepMask worth it?
Only if you want the vibration patterns. For blocking light alone, the $39 Manta does the core job for about $70 less.
What is the best sleep mask for side sleepers?
Manta's PRO mask ($85) is built for it, with C-shaped eye cups. The original Manta ($39) is the value pick.
Which sleep mask checks out on Glow?
The Loftie Sleep Mask ($25.99) and the KAILU Original Oversized Silk Eye Mask ($68) are both Ships from picks, so you check out with us.
Do silk sleep masks help with sleep lines?
KAILU says its smooth silk reduces friction that can show up as sleep lines. That is about how skin looks in the morning, not a long-term fix.
Keep reading
- The best mouth tape for sleeping
- The best silk pillowcase for hair and skin
- Sleep gifts for the friend who texts you at 2am
- The Glow Therapy Holiday Gift Guide 2026, or the whole BFCM Gift Edit
Updated November 17, 2026. Prices checked on this date. Retailer prices change, so check the product page before you buy.
Shop this story · 6
Links marked ↗ open the brand's site. We may earn a commission. It never changes our take.
Pass it on
Versus · 6 picks
Shop this story
BestsellerShop at Manta Sleep ↗SleepMask
"A blackout mask with a wind-down buzz. A splurge, but a cozy one."
Ships from Loftie
Ships from KAILU
Shop at Manta Sleep ↗Manta PRO Sleep Mask
"The sleep mask for side sleepers who have tried everything else."
Shop at Kitsch ↗Blush Contour Pillow Eye Mask
"Lash-safe blackout for $35. Same idea as the luxury masks, friendlier price."
We may earn a commission. It never changes our take.




