Shop at Rare Beauty ↗Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil
"Starts as a jelly, ends as an oil. Basically the main character of your makeup bag."
Versus
For your own bag, buy the Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil at $24 on our page today. It goes on as a jelly, turns into a light tinted oil, and is not sticky. It is the better value. Buy the Dior Lip Glow Oil at $40 when it is a gift: the cushiony shine is lovely, and the Dior name is part of what you are giving. Both wear off when you eat or drink. If clear shine is all you want, Byoma's lip oil is $11.99.
Links marked ↗ go to other shops. We may earn a commission. It never changes our take.
The short answer: For your own bag, buy the Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil at $24 on our page today. It goes on as a jelly, turns into a light tinted oil, and is not sticky. It is the better value. Buy the Dior Lip Glow Oil at $40 when it is a gift: the cushiony shine is lovely, and the Dior name is part of what you are giving. Both wear off when you eat or drink. If clear shine is all you want, Byoma's lip oil is $11.99.
Updated Nov 19, 2026.
Filling stockings? Start with Stocking stuffers under $25 she'll actually use, the BFCM Gift Edit, or The Glow Therapy Holiday Gift Guide 2026. Not sure what your skin wants? Take the 60-Second Quiz.
Disclosure: Every pick here is a Shop at link: it opens the brand's or retailer's site, and we may earn a commission. That never changes the verdict, and we label it every time. No brand paid for placement. Read our affiliate disclosure and how we pick. This comparison is built from each brand's product details and our product pages, not a wear trial.
| Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil | Dior Lip Glow Oil | |
|---|---|---|
| Price on our page, Nov 19, 2026 | $24 | $40 |
| Texture | Jelly that turns into a lightweight oil | Cushiony, glossy oil |
| Finish | Sheer wash of color, buildable | Sheer, juicy shine with a hint of color |
| Feel | Not sticky | Comfortable, not sticky |
| Size note | 3 mL, per our product page | Not listed on our page |
| Wear | Reapply after eating or drinking | Wears off quickly, plan to reapply |
| Best for | Daily wear, the better value | A gift that feels like a treat |
| Shop at | Rare Beauty | Sephora |
One swipe gives a sheer wash of color and layering builds a juicier pop. The jelly-to-oil texture feels fun and comfortable, and at $24 it is a fair price for something you will reach for every day.
Skip Rare Beauty if: you want long-wearing or transfer-proof color.
The catch: it is only 3 mL, and it is an oil, so you reapply after coffee.
The same idea in a solid stick, with gloss-like shine and buildable color, mess-free and easy without a mirror. It is lightly scented with fresh apple, which not everyone wants on their lips.
The lip oil that started the lip oil era, in a tube that looks good on a vanity. The shine is juicy without feeling goopy. At $40 you are mostly paying for the shine and the logo, and our product page says plainly that many cheaper oils come close. As a gift, that logo is the point.
Skip Dior if: you want long-wear color, or you are buying for yourself on a budget.
The catch: $40, and it wears off quickly.
| Pick | Price on our page, Nov 19, 2026 | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Byoma Liptide Lip Oil | $11.99 | Clear, non-sticky shine. Buy three |
| Tower 28 ShineOn Lip Oil Jelly | $16 | Fragrance-free, for sensitive lips |
| Laneige Glaze Craze Tinted Lip Serum | $22 | High shine with a tint, smells like dessert |
| Glow Recipe Glass Balm Lip Treatment | $22 | Balm comfort, gloss shine |
A lightweight lip oil with a peptide complex plus avocado and tamanu oils. It looks like gloss and feels like care. At this price, keep one in every bag.
Skip it if: you want color. This is clear shine.
A non-sticky lip oil and gloss hybrid with a touch of sheer color. It is fragrance-free, essential oil free and vegan, so it is the pick for sensitive lips.
Skip it if: you want bold, opaque color.
A tinted lip serum for visibly plump, high-shine lips. It also works over lipstick for extra gloss.
Skip it if: you dislike flavored or scented lip products.
A high-shine balm in sheer, juicy tints. The clear shade doubles as an overnight lip mask, so it covers day and night.
Skip it if: you want matte lips or real pigment.
Rituals, not routines. A lip mask at night, a lip oil by day, and one in your coat pocket. That is the whole system. If you are building a lip stocking, our Laneige vs Summer Fridays piece has the night half.
As a gift, yes. For yourself, only if you love it. It is comfortable and pretty, and cheaper oils come close.
We do not call anything an exact dupe. If you want a similar juicy shine for less, the Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil ($24) and Tower 28 ShineOn ($16) are the closest in spirit on our shelf.
Byoma at $11.99 or Tower 28 at $16. Both are under $20 and easy to like.
Updated Nov 19, 2026. Prices checked on this date. Retailer prices change, so check the product page before you buy.
Shop this story · 7
Links marked ↗ open the brand's site. We may earn a commission. It never changes our take.
Pass it on
Versus · 7 picks
Shop at Rare Beauty ↗"Starts as a jelly, ends as an oil. Basically the main character of your makeup bag."
NewShop at Rare Beauty ↗"Lip oil, gloss and lipstick walked into a bar. This is what came out."
NewShop at Sephora ↗
Sleeper hitShop at Byoma ↗
BestsellerShop at Tower 28 ↗"Gloss shine, balm comfort, no sticky hair-in-your-lipgloss moments."
TrendingShop at Laneige ↗"Donut-themed lip serum. Yes, it smells like dessert. No, we're not mad."
Shop at Glow Recipe ↗"Lips that look like a glazed donut. Named after an icy Korean dessert, naturally."
We may earn a commission. It never changes our take.
Your bag is giving minimalist.
Start with what's bugging you, or let the quiz do the thinking.
The stuff you loved that ships from other brands. Tap to shop it there.
We may earn a commission on these. It never changes our take.