Skip the $79 greens powder: 6 swaps that work better

First, the math

AG1, the greens powder that launched a thousand podcast ads, was listed at $79 a month on subscription, or $99 one-time for 30 servings, in a 2026 pricing breakdown (Nutrola; note that Nutrola sells a competing product, so check AG1's site). A Boston Globe piece priced AG1 Next Gen at $100 for 30 servings and Live it Up Super Greens at $60 for a 30-day supply (Boston Globe).

At $79 a month, that's $948 a year. For reference, that's more than four GlowMax masks. We did the math so you'd feel something.

What the experts actually said

From that same Boston Globe report:

• Nutritionists described the benefits of these powders as "largely unproven," and the FDA has not evaluated their health claims.
• Dietitian Maddie Pasquariello said some ingredients are included at sub-clinical levels, where they likely do nothing, and others at "levels far above what you need," and that powders are "not a substitute for whole foods."
• Dr. Mahtab Jafari of UC Irvine: "The marketing is way ahead of the actual science."
• Luciana Soares of Johnson & Wales University warned about possible "toxicity and drug-supplement interactions," and said falling short of an optimal intake "does not necessarily mean they need supplementation."
• AG1's VP said its products are meant to complement a healthy diet, and AG1 says its Next Gen formula is backed by placebo-controlled trials. The Globe didn't assess those studies, and neither have we.

So the honest framing: a greens powder isn't poison. It's just an expensive answer to a question you probably haven't asked yet. Here's how to ask it.

Swap 1: If you wanted more vegetables → frozen greens

A bag of frozen spinach or mixed vegetables is the most boring sentence on this website and also the best one. Experts in the Globe piece are clear that powders aren't a substitute for whole foods. Frozen veg keeps for months, needs no prep, and disappears into eggs, pasta, soup, rice or a smoothie.

The catch: You have to remember it's in the freezer. Put it at eye level.

Swap 2: If you wanted "gut health" → fiber from food

The Boston Globe notes the USDA identifies fiber, potassium and vitamin D as nutrients most Americans don't get enough of. Fiber is the easy one to fix with groceries: beans, lentils, oats, berries, whole grains. Add slowly if you're not used to it. Your stomach will appreciate the warning.

The catch: Fiber isn't sexy and doesn't come in a jar with a scoop. That's sort of the point.

Swap 3: If you suspect a real gap → labs first, then something targeted

The single best "wellness" purchase might be asking your doctor for bloodwork at your next checkup. Then you're filling an actual gap instead of a theoretical one. If a doctor suggests a multivitamin, a straightforward one costs about half of a monthly greens powder.

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

The catch: Read the label for biotin. The FDA has warned that biotin can interfere with certain lab tests, including a troponin test used to help diagnose heart attacks (TCTMD). Tell your doctor about every supplement you take, especially before blood work.

Swap 4: If you wanted "glowing skin" → sunscreen, every day

If a greens ad sold you on glow, here's the unglamorous truth: the American Academy of Dermatology says sunscreen "can also help prevent premature skin aging, such as wrinkles and age spots," and recommends broad-spectrum SPF 30 or higher (AAD). We can't find a greens powder with evidence that strong for skin.

Both $22. One is a sunscreen, one is a moisturizer with SPF 50, so pick based on whether you want one step or two.

The catch: It only works if you wear it daily and reapply when you're outside. The best sunscreen is the one you'll actually put on.

Swap 5: If you wanted energy → protect your sleep

No powder fixes being tired because you slept five hours. The CDC's list of basics: the same bedtime and wake time every day, a quiet, relaxing, cool bedroom, devices off at least 30 minutes before bed, no large meals or alcohol before bed, and no caffeine in the afternoon or evening (CDC).

If light leaks into your room at 5am, a good mask is the cheapest blackout curtain you'll ever buy.

The catch: The mask is the easy part. The phone-down-30-minutes part is the hard part.

Swap 6: If you just like the ritual → keep the ritual, change the cup

Sometimes the powder was never about nutrients. It was about a morning moment that felt like taking care of yourself. Keep that. Make it a glass of water and something you actually enjoy, or a five-minute stretch, or a walk around the block before you open your laptop. The ritual is the part that works.

About the greens product we carry

Full transparency: we carry Ritual's Creatine Greens at $65.91. The same rules apply to it. It's not a substitute for vegetables. If you specifically want creatine plus a greens blend in one scoop and the price works for you, it's a reasonable option. If you were buying it "to be healthy," start with swaps one through five.

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

The cheat sheet

We may earn a commission from some links. It never changes our take.